Skip to main content

Table 1 RRI and the evolution of responsibility paradigms

From: Turning the tide or surfing the wave? Responsible Research and Innovation, fundamental rights and neoliberal virtues

Paradigm

Criterion of ascription

Mean of realisation

Target

Dimension

Orientation in time

Responsibility dimensions

Regulating mechanism

Fault

Liability

Sanction

Negative outcomes

Individual

Retrospective

Liability-responsibility

Hard law

Risk

Damage

Compensation

Negative outcomes

Systemic

Prospective/Retrospective

Causality-responsibility

Hard law

Safety

Uncertainty

Precaution

Negative outcomes

Collective

Prospective/Anticipative

Capacity-responsibility

Hard law/Soft law

RRI

Responsiveness

Participation

Negative and positive outcomes

Collaborative

Prospective/Proactive

Virtue-responsibility

Self-regulation/Soft law/Hard Law

  1. Adapted from Arnaldi, Gorgoni and Pariotti 2016